WITCHCRAFT
A collection of magical practices that came to inspire hostile views about prophecy, exemplified in two plays by Shakespeare. Witches, meaning women credited with magical powers, have existed from time immemorial. In medieval Europe, most were individual practitioners, often old and solitary. Some, such as village wisewomen and healers, were more or less approved or at least tolerated. A reputed ability to see the future could give them status as fortune-tellers. With others, the popular image was sinister, owing to superstitions about the evil eye and malignant spell casting. But they were not seen as particularly important or as a threat to society. Dante, in his account of hell, imagines some as resident there, but he dismisses them in three lines, scornfully and anonymously. They are “wretched women” who have neglected ordinary household tasks to occupy themselves with wax images and potions. Stories of medieval witch-hunts are almost wholly fictitious; there was not the motivation.
However, the last part of the fifteenth century brought a change in beliefs and attitudes, leading to a paranoid witch mania and a persecution lasting for more than 200 years. One major factor was a papal pronouncement in 1484. Witchcraft was given a new diabolic meaning and extended to involve both sexes. Where the delusion flourished, the dominant opinion, both Catholic and Protestant, was that magical activities in general were elements in a vast conspiracy run by the devil and his minions, for the affliction of humanity and the ruin of souls. Now, a witch meant anyone supposedly taking part in this conspiracy. The conception could cover witchcraft in the old sense, including fortune-telling, but it covered a great deal more besides. Witches, once isolated, were now thought to conspire together by flying (on broomsticks or otherwise) to mass gatherings where they met the Evil One for unhallowed rites.
The first witch-hunters’ handbook was a volume entitled Malleus Maleficarum, the Hammer of Witches, by two priests of the Dominican order. They described the ways in which Satan’s host of demons could operate through consenting humans—usually women, but not necessarily—enabling them to work all manner of mischief. In that belief, as it would presently be developed, suspects were tortured until they confessed to satanic dealings and then put to death. Those who condemned them could cite the Bible, which contains such injunctions as “Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live.” The overall total has often been wildly exaggerated, but it remains terrible. It was probably 40,000 or 50,000, perhaps 10,000 of them being male.
Despite this figure, it should not be thought that persecution was universal or continuous. Eastern Europe was free from it. England, with several hundred killed, suffered far less severely than Germany or Switzerland. Scotland was more witch-conscious, and its king James VI considered himself an expert on the subject, a notion that had literary consequences.
In that context, an opinion laid down by Saint Augustine in the fifth century, and now revived, affected ideas of prophecy. Among witches’ unholy deeds in the Malleus survey is that they “show to others occult things and certain future events, by the information of devils.” The authors recognize, as Augustine does, that foresight may have a natural cause and may be due simply to intelligent anticipation. But when witches, “by the information of devils,” reveal the future, it will be to lead others astray and to do harm. If anyone relies on such forecasts, only misfortune can come of it. Though the authors of the Old Testament knew nothing of the devil or the diabolic view of witchcraft, it supplied at least one justification. When Saul tries to learn his future from the witch of Endor, it is made quite clear that his action is wrong.
Shakespeare twice illustrates these notions. He confronts the prophetic issue in a very early play, Henry VI, part 1. Much of the action takes place in France, where territory conquered by Henry V is being lost. The French recovery is inspired by La Pucelle, Joan of Arc, and since an Elizabethan audience would not have relished a presentation of English defeat, Shakespeare attributes Joan’s success to witchcraft in the contemporary sense. She makes a pretense of holiness but is, in fact, evil, with preternatural powers bestowed on her by fiends whom she addresses as
- Ye choice spirits that admonish me
- And give me signs of future accidents.
This is close to Malleus Maleficarum. When the fiends desert her, she comes to an ignominious end.
Shakespeare did not return to the subject until 1606 or thereabouts, when he wrote Macbeth. King James of Scotland had become king of England also, and his London establishment included a company of players. Shakespeare was one of them, and he probably wrote Macbeth for performance at court. It is about a Scottish monarch in the eleventh century whose story, or legend, involved prophecies. Dramatizing it, Shakespeare had to take account of his royal patron’s interest in witchcraft. According to the chronicle that he used, before Macbeth was king his accession to the throne was foretold by a trio of mysterious women, possibly fairy-folk. The success of this prediction led him, long afterward, to trust promises by soothsayers that lured him to his downfall.
In Shakespeare’s treatment, the three prophetesses become witches as pictured in his own time, with demonic “masters,” and they have a continuing role using prophecy to ruin Macbeth. First, the promise of kingship impels him to fulfil it himself by murdering the present king and seizing the crown. His dreadful crime leads to others. He has no peace of mind, and when he suspects that enemies may act against him, he seeks out the witches, or “weird sisters” as Shakespeare calls them: he is “bent to know, by the worst means, the worst.” At this second encounter their fiendish masters, speaking through apparitions, make predictions that apparently assure him of safety. Their words are ambiguous, but, believing that these beings “know all mortal consequences,” Macbeth takes them at face value. Realizing the truth too late, he is overthrown and killed. In the play, the old story has acquired a theme of diabolic corruption and deception through prophecy, which belongs to the fantasies of witch-theorists like King James. Macbeth is the only Shakespearean tragic hero who ends in damnation and despair.
It need not be assumed that Shakespeare subscribed to the witch mania himself. His plays show no traces of it except in these two cases where the motif is functional. A later dramatist, Goethe, brings demonized witchcraft into his version of the story of Faust, with swarms of witches flying to meet their hellish masters on Walpurgis Night. Yet he lived long after the witch mania was over and certainly did not believe such things literally. Nevertheless, in defiance of all enlightenment, the sinister mythology still affects popular images of witches, even comic ones.




